Further RPG thoughts
Apr. 12th, 2020 06:28 pmI feel like I've finally speculated and played enough I might be ready to run some of the other ideas I have in mind. Current forerunners, something set on Barrayar, and a swords-and-sorcery wander-the-landscape-fighting-dark-lords.
But I keep having further ideas for what can work well.
One is to borrow the idea from various places of a "reputation" track, where progress is measured in terms of how much, when NPCs meet you, they treat you as a famous wizard/scary badass/etc/etc. Or how much your standing with your personal god, or patron organisation, etc rises and how much support and lattitude they're willing to give you. Since having responsibility is fun, but only when it feels real.
The other is, that in order for players to relax and have fun, they have to be able to go into fights clowning about and it not being a big deal if they lose. Be able to play their character and have the scared one and the CHARGE one, etc, etc. But you only really get to that point if they can try things out and see what happens. Which is POSSIBLE if you have a "beaten up but victorious" mode (i.e. a big buffer of healing potions always). But maybe easier if you assume that losing means "embarrassingly driven back" or at worst "left for dead" not "throat slit". So I think I should try building that in from the start, both in terms of plot (i.e. have most enemies have a reason to skirmish and retreat, and fighting for a goal which can be lost without dying), and in terms of mechanics (i.e. make dying default to 'knocked out' not 'dead', and make more forgiving healing, but be more ready to provide informal consequences for losing, like just acting like it was a failure.)
But I keep having further ideas for what can work well.
One is to borrow the idea from various places of a "reputation" track, where progress is measured in terms of how much, when NPCs meet you, they treat you as a famous wizard/scary badass/etc/etc. Or how much your standing with your personal god, or patron organisation, etc rises and how much support and lattitude they're willing to give you. Since having responsibility is fun, but only when it feels real.
The other is, that in order for players to relax and have fun, they have to be able to go into fights clowning about and it not being a big deal if they lose. Be able to play their character and have the scared one and the CHARGE one, etc, etc. But you only really get to that point if they can try things out and see what happens. Which is POSSIBLE if you have a "beaten up but victorious" mode (i.e. a big buffer of healing potions always). But maybe easier if you assume that losing means "embarrassingly driven back" or at worst "left for dead" not "throat slit". So I think I should try building that in from the start, both in terms of plot (i.e. have most enemies have a reason to skirmish and retreat, and fighting for a goal which can be lost without dying), and in terms of mechanics (i.e. make dying default to 'knocked out' not 'dead', and make more forgiving healing, but be more ready to provide informal consequences for losing, like just acting like it was a failure.)