Jo Walton

Feb. 9th, 2008 01:44 pm
jack: (Default)
I just re-read Tooth and Claw. Firstly, does anyone have a nice list of the ranking of the noble titles? I keep getting them in the wrong order.

Secondly, I'm curious, does anyone keep notes on that sort of thing when they read? Possibly I sometimes read too quickly. In an intricate detective novel or similar it would certainly make sense. But it always feels over the top for anything else, even if if there were a list of N things or characters you could keep a lot more straight if you had a little list of the names.

Thirdly, had anyone read any of the Farthing series?
jack: (Default)
I had another several days worth of rant about mobile phones, market segmentation, confusopolies, complicated metaphors involving concatenations of pseudo-linear functions, jumentous companies, and other things that make my spell checker throw up its hands in dismay.

But I decided to talk about dragons instead. I know people whose animal is a panda, or an elephant. That has some individuality. Somehow dragons are too *obvious*. But hey, I have to accept I can do something well but not have to be the first, the only, or the best. I like dragons.

Why do dragons eat princesses? It's like in the matrix. Princesses are not a good source of nutrition, people. For starters, there's not very many of them. In LOTR there are no female characters at all (though there are a relatively high proportion of scions), Smaug would be toast. And humans aren't particularly interesting metabolically.

If you just want food, stick to cows. If they're eating for nutrition, Dragons are in an evolutionary dead end. Sea-serpents, crocodiles, fireflies, etc probably do better as a species, however badass a dragon is one-on-one. Princesses didn't even EXIST for millions of years, any dragon who could eat anything else would be at a great advantage.

No, it's a power thing. They get off on making the kingdom dance to their tune.

What do Dragons get from their food that isn't meat? They need to eat souls. (This is also why carnivores always have so much more oomph than herbivores, they recharge their mana an awful lot more. And why the more militant the religion the more specific the kinds of meat you eat. You may notice at about this point in the post that I'm making up things that aren't true.)

What is a soul? I'd normally say something else, but here I think we're talking about accumulated life experiences. There may be something else, but we're talking about that which is eaten.

Which is why dragons want princesses. There's two basic things you want out of life, adventure and luxury. Knights have adventure, but dragons don't have to form convoluted plans to find knights, they just have to sit down somewhere and demand princesses. Dragons want a taste of the high life, and they want to feel special, hence princesses.

Also notice dragons in stories are male. Female dragons are larger, more majestic, more intelligent, and generally so successful they don't hang around terrorising kingdoms. And all the stories are written by knights' bard squires, and jousting with a female isn't chivalrous to them.

That means the bards, like vampires, have a sexual metaphor thing going on, which means princesses. And preferably unmarried princesses, being so much more tragic. (And besides, life experiences of being married off to powerful ugly foreign potentates probably isn't a dragon's cup of tea.)

Do you think there's a story in this? I'm thinking reversing a few things, where the knight is the evil soul-eater, (who starts off just big and brash, but is shortly wearing all black armour, and then pushing back his visor to reveal only swirling darkness underneath) and the princess is the hero, and she and her family band together with the dragon to defeat him. Basically, I want to ask the_alchemist if I can rip off the royal family in her book.

Dragons

Aug. 2nd, 2006 12:50 am
jack: (Default)
I'm depressed and need hugs. But fortunately it hasn't been long enough since my last whiny post, so instead I'll cheer myself up by listing all the reasons I like dragons:

1. Tradition. There are other popular monsters. Vampires are in vogue. But if martians wanted to characterise humanity with a fictional beast, I think they could do worse than a dragon.

2. Coolness. They're big (even the little ones), beautiful, bad-ass... We love whales and dinosaurs and elephants. I'm always moved by Kipling's descriptions ("An elephant doesn't run. If he wants to catch up a steam train he will, but he won't run.") It's just amazing that something natural can be so powerful.

3. The metaphor. In so many different stories dragons mirror us in some way. Does anyone sufficiently important have a corresponding dragon form? Are dragons and humans different evolutions from the same being? Are dragons our darkness taken form? Are they a greater intellegence completely unconcerned with us? Whichever way, they're a philosophical point as well as an animal.

4. Relatedly, they inevitably have magic resistance, or magic, or psionics, or wisdom, or kevlar skin, or whatever local equivalent keeps them from being easy prey to things other than direct force.

5. The physics. OK, it falls down here. Every attempt to make dragons pseudoscientific, from Pern's teleporting firestone-eating dragons, to Chess with a Dragon's implausibly large dragons, to starfaring dragons, to flammable-gas regurgitating dragons is at best satisfactory. None ring true and many are awful. Maybe PTerry got the best explanation with the "They're a disaster area without magic, but with it they're amazing" schtick, only by recognising the problems and invoking magic.

6. The independence. A human one day chatting to a thief and the next razing a village would be ill or evil. Smaug is just who he is, and seeing someone acting outside the moral framework is both refreshingly straightforward, and puts your species in perspective.

7. The cult. So many powerful symbols are ruined by casual use, but almost any variation on the word dragon is an acceptable and often impressive name for an illdefined boding :)

8. The cachet. If you kill a demon, you almost certainly used some sort of trick with a mirror. If you killed a vampire, you probably staked it in a weak place near the heart, or brought it to light in a crowded place and robbed its mystique. If you kill a tiger you probably didn't need to. But if you killed a dragon, big or small, you'll get respect anywhere. And dragonhide clothing is mockable by *no-one*

Active Recent Entries